This picture is the first painting in oils sold by JMW Turner from the walls of the Royal Academy. Turner first sketched Dunstanburgh Castle during a tour of the north of England in 1797. The dramatic fourteenth-century ruin high on the cliffs of the Northumbrian coast became a favourite subject. A number of charcoal drawings of the ruin, seen from various aspects, appear in Turner’s ‘North of England’ sketchbook (Tate Britain, London), and the castle was also the subject for a series of tone and colour studies, several watercolours and two oil paintings. It is hardly surprising that the young Turner, with a growing interest in the classics and in history painting, found this theatrical and poignant scene so alluring. This painting is an early working of what was to become Turner’s grand theme: man’s heroic fragility in the face of the powers of nature. By depicting the castle as an ‘heroic’ presence above dark, soaring cliffs and a violent ocean, Turner invokes a sense of the Sublime, an aesthetic popularised in the eighteenth century by the British statesman and writer Edmund Burke (1729–1797).
X-radiography taken prior to recent cleaning reveals a building in the centre left of the composition painted out by the artist, and alterations to the headland and horizon.